Posts tagged: bonds

Spot-Futures Parity

We can be a little bit more precise concerning the relationship between spot and futures prices for financial futures. To illustrate, suppose we had a futures contract on shares of common stock in a single company (actually there are no such contracts in the U.S.). This particular stock does not pay dividends.
For concreteness, suppose the contract calls for delivery of 1,000 shares of stock in one year. The current (i.e., cash or spot) price is $50 per share. Also, 12-month T-bills are yielding 6 percent. What should the futures price be? To answer, notice that you can buy 1,000 shares of stock for $50 per share, or $50,000 total. You can eliminate all of the risk associated with this purchase by selling one futures contract. The net effect of this transaction is that you have created a risk-free asset. Since the risk-free rate is 6 percent, your investment must have a future value of $50,000 × 1.06 = $53,000. In other words, the futures price should be $53 per share.
Suppose the futures price is, in fact, $52 per share. What would you do? To make a great deal of money, you would short 1,000 shares of stock at $50 per share and invest the $50,000 proceeds at 6 percent. Simultaneously, you would buy one futures contract.
At the end of the year, you would have $53,000. You would use $52,000 to buy the stock to fulfill your obligation on the futures contract and then return the stock to close out the short position. You pocket $1,000. This is just another example of cash-futures arbitrage.
More generally, if we let F be the futures price, S be the spot price, and r be the risk-free rate, then our example illustrates that
F = S(1 + r)
In other words, the futures price is simply the future value of the spot price, calculated at the risk-free rate. This is the famous spot-futures parity condition. This condition must hold in the absence of cash-futures arbitrage opportunities.

Cash-Futures Arbitrage

Intuitively, you might think that there is a close relationship between the cash price of a commodity and its futures price. If you do, then your intuition is quite correct. In fact, your intuition is backed up by strong economic argument and more than a century of experience observing the simultaneous operation of cash and futures markets.
As a routine matter, cash and futures prices are closely watched by market professionals. To understand why, suppose you notice that spot gold is trading for $400 per ounce while the two-month futures price is $450 per ounce. Do you see a profit opportunity?
You should, because buying spot gold today at $400 per ounce while simultaneously selling gold futures at $450 per ounce locks in a $50 per ounce profit. True, gold has storage costs (you have to put it somewhere), and a spot gold purchase ties up capital that could be earning interest. However, these costs are small relative to the $50 per ounce gross profit, which works out to be $50 / $400 = 12.5% per two months, or about 100% per year (with compounding). Furthermore, this profit is risk-free! Alas, in reality, such easy profit opportunities are the stuff of dreams.
Earning risk-free profits from an unusual difference between cash and futures prices is called cash-futures arbitrage. In a competitive market, cash-futures arbitrage has very slim profit margins. In fact, the profit margins are almost imperceptible when they exist at all.